DOCTORS DON'T ALWAYS REPORT THEIR INCOMPETENT PEERS
A new study suggests that doctors don't always report incompetent or impaired colleagues, even though almost all think they should. The study, published in the Annals of Internal Medicine, is believed to be the first of its kind. Researchers evaluated the extent to which doctors support and adhere to professional standards. More than 3,500 doctors were surveyed for the study.
Of the 1,662 doctors who responded, 96% said physicians should always report colleagues who are impaired, incompetent, or make a medical mistake. However, of those who had direct knowledge of peer incompetence within the past three years, only 55% made a report.
Cardiologists, pediatricians, family practitioners, surgeons, internists, and anesthesiologists were among the specialists surveyed. Those least likely to report a fellow doctor for incompetence were cardiologists and practitioners. According to the CEO of the American College of Cardiology, Jack Lewin, cardiologists may be more apt to deal with problems within their practice since they tend to practice in groups. He also said many doctors may avoid reporting colleagues for fear of being sued.
Within the legal world, this environment may contribute to the significant difficulty finding physicians who are willing to testify against their peers in a court of law. If they won't report them to the appropriate medical oversight agencies, testifying against them in a public forum is even more unlikely.
There is no question that there needs to be some kind of whistleblower protection for doctors so that they no longer fear reporting colleagues. There needs to be accountability for doctors who make medical mistakes. If they won't report each other, who will report them?
Continue reading " DOCTORS DON'T ALWAYS REPORT THEIR INCOMPETENT PEERS " »